December 11, 2016

What Gary Johnson Should Have Said About Legalizing Heroin

maureen-morella-cnnIn one of the more predictable moments from last night’s CNN Libertarian Town Hall, Gary Johnson was confronted by the mother of a young man who ingested a single line of heroin and was disabled for life. Jacob Sullum has already weighed in on what Johnson should have said from a libertarian perspective, but his thoughtful and informed piece is still too verbose for a political campaign.

Libertarians like to make fun of “sound bites” and slogans, but if they ever want to win an election for dog catcher, much less President of the United States, they need to face the reality that people stop listening and stop reading when the answer is long and developed. Here is how Gary Johnson should have answered:

“Ms. Morella, I am very sorry to hear about what happened to your son. It’s a tragedy. But I have to tell you the truth, even though it’s not what you came here to hear. What happened to your son may not have happened if heroin were legal. Here’s why:

When drugs are illegal, they’re sold by criminals who have no business address. You can’t sue them if they’re negligent or prosecute them when they willfully defraud you.

Reactions like your son’s usually occur with what’s called a “hot load,” meaning there was another substance mixed with the heroin. If the heroin he ingested were sold by a legitimate business in the light of day, there would be an immediate investigation. If the product had dangerous ingredients in it or otherwise wasn’t what the package said it was, the owner would be sued. If it were discovered he did it intentionally, he’d be prosecuted.

Ms. Morella, no one in America is concerned that when they buy a bottle of gin, there is going to be foreign substances in it that are going to kill them. But they used to be. Know when that was? When alcohol was prohibited. They called it “bath tub gin” and tragedies like your son’s occurred all the time when only criminals could sell alcohol.

There is absolutely no difference between alcohol prohibition then and drug prohibition today. Your son’s tragedy is the 2016 equivalent of what happened to people drinking bath tub gin.

Prohibiting alcohol also led to the rise of heavily armed, violent gangs like Al Capone’s. You don’t see sellers of alcohol today behaving like Capone. Do you know why? Because that’s not how business is conducted in the absence of prohibition.

You said, “Can you people in positions of power please get rid of the drugs?” I’m the only politician who is going to tell you the truth. No. We’ve had a war on drugs for decades and there are more drugs now than ever. It’s a little like the government war on terrorism. Is there less terrorism today than fifteen years ago or more?

What we can do is stop subsidizing criminal drug dealers by taking away their legitimate competition. If you want someone to tell you what you want to hear about drugs, I’m sure Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton will be happy to do so. Their parties have told you they’ll get rid of drugs for fifty years. If you want the truth, the only way to make America safer is to end prohibition and allow all drugs to be sold like alcohol.”

The answer above is chock full of sound bites. Sound bites become headlines. That’s how you get your message out to 315 million people.

It also answers the woman’s question, something Johnson’s rambling answer failed to do.

This is the way Gary Johnson has to start answering questions if he’s going to take any advantage of the opportunity the Libertarian Party is being presented with during this election. Hopefully, his debate coach is listening.

Tom Mullen is the author of Where Do Conservatives and Liberals Come From? And What Ever Happened to Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness? Part One and A Return to Common Sense: Reawakening Liberty in the Inhabitants of America.

Comments

  1. Lynn Atherton Bloxham says:

    As I keep saying: Gary Johnson is a nice sincere guy who has put in hours of work for the libertarian cause now. BUT he desperately needs this type of coaching. Frankly I wish he had studied for 4 years instead of climbing a mountain. there are “mountains” to climb and I had hoped he was reading, studying, thinking and asking for assistance. Perhaps he needs to be deluged with suggestions. This is not second guessing or hind sight. Many libertarians have been practicing these answers for years. Thanks for your good answer. Hope you send it to Gary.

    • Robert Taylor says:

      Not until a well known personality (nationally) steps up to run for Prez. on the Libertarian ticket and/or someone like the Koch brothers with a veritable plethora of dollars that they will spend (as Trump did), I fear the LP will never find real traction.

  2. Gary Lost me back in 2012 Ya he needs something just not sure what that is … perhaps a spine .. Cant make it to the presidency on the backs of others> That Irreparable…

  3. Okay, Mr Mullen. I’ll take your whole brilliant argument against drug prohibition, except for the sloppy comparison of the War on Drugs to the War on Terror. Really? Is terrorism a victimless crime? Do you really think terrorists would throw in the towel rather than the bomb if mass murdering people for political reasons were legalized? Please.

    But the entirety of the rest of your argument is beautifully stated and should be tattooed on the inside of Gary Johnson’s arm so he doesn’t forget it.

Leave a Reply